Headlight Bezel Question

Clarification: Don't try to polish anything but the edge, repaint the painted part. Not only will it look silly, but you will find all the creases from the stamping (I know this from trying). Just mask and repaint the center. You will also want to do the bar at the top of the grill to match. It's kind of a hassle, but you can make it look REALLY good if you take your time.