Do you think I got screwed, or is it just part of the hobby?

I am with crazy guy,its up to you to pull the motor,there not going to do that lol. Now BE THERE when they pull it apart,insist that they Waite until your there to see first hand what happened,we all know using oil is rings or valves.I think you will have no problems with that shop.Good luck and please let us know how all this ends up.