if that ashtray is going into Panther Pink 70 Hemi Cuda Convertible, then it is worth every penny you pay for it. If that same ashtray is going into a Green 318 Baracuda with a 3 speed, then you are an idiot for paying $615.
There is the problem now even a crapy ashtry is going to have a minimum bid of $400
so the guy with the green 318 3 speed baracuda cant aford an ashtry
By the way i just got my a-body console in the mail today and dam i lucked out it had a crappy pict and the guy did not bother to wipe it off so 80 bucks later its at my house icleaned it up and i can run it as is, thing looks great so ebay is not all bad