White or Black top?

I'm thinking of changing my black vinyl top to white. The car does have black interior, which I could change, and came originally with a white top. The only thing that is stopping me is how the white top would look with the tinted windows, which I want to keep (for heat reasons). I'm kinda biased to a white top, which I had on a Swinger when I was younger. I know everyone has opinions and here at work the guys are divided about half, half. The picture with the black top is original and the white top is photo shopped. Interested in any and all opinions and or reasoning. Thanks