What brand of cam? Were there springs recommended for the cam? I put a Comp cam (very similar in lift) in my engine and they recommended the 901-16 (I think) springs with damper. I have a slight tick with my Comp cam and after some research discovered that some of the Comp cams with their fast ramp drop allow the valves to close quicker giving a clicking sound. My car still does it, but have not noticed and problems as of yet.
Is it possible your springs don't have enough pressure?