Rear Quarters - Sherman or Goodmark?

Hi Guys, getting ready to replace my drivers side rear quarter panel on my 69 Barracuda. I want to cut the panel an inch or two below the top crease just above the fuel cap.

I see AMD makes a nice replacement panel but I don't need the whole panel. Both Goodmark and Sherman make replacements that are more suitable, I think.

Sherman #250-50BL
Goodmark #2034917

Any comments or experience on which make is the best?

Thanks for your help.

Patrick