repainting- OEM Rally Wheel color- opinions?

If you look at the rally's with rings the 1/2 Holes are completed with the reflection in the ring. Silver is how they were designed to reflect. Without rings I really don't think it matters what color they are. I have seen them all colors over the years. With just the center any color you prefer is good. With The rings silver is the look. Although silver looks correct without rings because they came that way on Sizzlers, and Twister's. so what ever looks good to you.

The wheels you buy from Stockton or Wheels Vintique come with a primer that looks silver. They will rust if not painted. Because they already started rusting under the prime. You will be better off getting them blasted and putting epoxy primer and paint . Or powder coat which would be the best for durability.