Which silver paint? To Clear or not to Clear?

I was going to do the Krylon Paint I talked about in the first post but it looked too mirror like once it dried after I test it.

Krylon left & Rustoleum on right:






Its hard to tell in the pictures but the Krylon is very shiny and mirror-like.

Which Kylon was that: 1403 or 51519 ??

I've seen the 1403 against original paint rims and it was dead on.