Solid vs Hydraulic

The reason I asked this question is the machine shop is pushing the hyd. I told him that goes against everything Ive read. I followed hughes breakin procedure by the letter inner springs removed and used there breakin oil, carefully checking adjustments several times and still lost two lobes. I have a 260 dur and 630 lift solid roller picked out. I just needed some reinforcement on my decision.

Thanks to all that had some imput
you will be hard pressed to touch the power potential of a soil roller and if your car is doing heavy track time then go for it, but if you do mostly street time I would go a different direction...my two cents.