I see flights from Orlando (not too far from Bunnell) to Providence (looks like 90ish minutes from you) for $111 one-way today/tomorrow or $91 on Saturday. That's cheaper and faster than $200 gas.
Hope that helps!
http://www.southwest.com/flight/shortcut/select-flight.html?fromShowItinerary=1&disc=sdc%3A1370536518.975000%3A2bbae_nsRq6UyMYXm0kVbA%407747AEF90BC98D4D29E84050B2CE82AA7869D0AC&ss=0&int=&companyName=&cid=
