1965 Dodge Dart Charger

The p/n you're thinking of is 1851 658. It was the specified P/N in every factory parts catalogue through '72. It also appears in '73 as "Long type", next to a new-that-year part number for "short type"; the shorter oil filter was introduced in '73 for some applications that could no longer accommodate the long filter because of engine bay configuration changes. The 1851 658 filter did have various appearances over the years. And as you note, the service replacement filters came in various versions, too.