I've seen worse for 67-69 Barracuda parts.
I think there are a lot of newbies with these cars. They aren't very savvy.
That's why there is a such a sudden influx of people jumping on the bandwagon parting out 67-69 Barracudas to take advantage of somebody willing to pay $500 for window moldings.
I think supply and demand is catching up. I've recently seen some parts advertised at a typical higher asking price and the parts are not moving.
I just bought a pair of 68 Barracuda grilles at Fall Fling for $30. One was cracked missing some fin pieces. The other was cracked but just needed to be glued back. So not directly comparable to this non cracked $132 grille. But the one is an extremely easy repair.