Am I asking for too much?

It wouldn't bring that around here but the price depends on the market in a given area. Green car prices are well under other cars prices. I put up two 1998 Ford Taurus cars for sale the same week. One was silver with 168K miles and had been wrecked on the right rear quarter panel but was repaired nicely but as usual the silver paint didn't match plus had at least 5 owners. The second one was green with under 100K miles, never wrecked, perfect paint, two owners and everything on the car was mint with all the maintenance records since new. Both car were really nice with no mechanical issues. The silver one sold two days later while the green one took about a week to sell. The green one sold for $500 less than the silver one even though it was the best buy.