direct connection style spoiler

I have both as well, and an original DC spoiler too. :D

Of the three, the one made by showcarsrob (from Canada) is probably the best. The original DC spoilers are ABS and fairly thin and flexible. Although the one I have isn't cracked, I can see how it would be pretty easy for them to end up that way, especially around the mounting holes. I was thinking about using a high density foam or something similar to fill the DC spoiler before mounting it on the car, but then I found the fiberglass version from showcarsrob. The one made by showcarsrob is a really good fiberglass copy of the DC spoiler, and seems to me like it would hold up better as its a little heavier, a little thicker, and fiberglass instead of ABS. It would still need a some finishing if you wanted to paint it a glossy body color, although I'm going to give it try with a coat or two of plasti-dip and see how that turns out. The "smooth" version from eBay would definitely need some work. It will fit, but the one I got would need some fitting before you could even bolt it on. And it calls to be mounted from the bottom with some lag bolts, which I don't think have any place on cars. I don't think it would be that difficult to take care of, but you'd need to put a little work into it. If you don't like all the mounting screws on the DC or replica DC spoiler, it would still be the way to go as it would be less work to make it fit than to glass over all the mounting holes on the other one.

And yes, eventually I will be selling the extra's, which will probably be the original DC spoiler and the "smooth" copy of it. I do want to get one mounted on my car first though...