Project Plain Jane
While the Sherman panel is far from perfect,the flaws are easily workable. It is a bit on the thin side however. And it was shipped in a box about 4 ft too long and surrounded by large balled up plain brown paper. Surprised it arrived undamaged. Overall I would give it maybe a grade of C,strictly average.
The Amd panel is much thicker and sturdier. Seems to be well made and I bet it fits well. Tentative grade of B,pending fitment.If it fits like a factory piece I will give it an A.
Im a bit of a cynic when it comes to body panels,having worked in bodyshops for many years and seeing a lot of high grade panel.