Stop in for a cup of coffee
I just did a quick search for the rims on car parts in my are and the rims range from $150 - $300.
The $300 say that they are "like new insurance quality" for $294 each...
There are some in the $150 range that say "no damage" but I would look at them in person before buying.
when I bought some spare rims for the Jeeps so I could put full size spares on them, I went to the yard and one of the rims had a good scrape on the edge of the rim about 60° around and may have gotten a little bent in the process, so I didn't get that one, but found two other good ones. It's best to look at them in person or have them send you a good picture of the actual part before you hand over any money...
So if you can get the insurance company to cover the $300 per rim plus tires, you may have a good deal if you can then get a good clean set of the "bargain" $150 rims...