Distributor is 270 degrees off?

Thanks guys. The car is about 25 min away at my in-laws, so I'll have to update tomorrow evening. At the 0 mark on my balancer, the number 1 piston was at the top of the cylinder. The only thing that was changed when I pulled the motor was the oil pan gasket, so I highly doubt this is anything broken or way out of whack, the car has ran great for the 2 years I've had it.

Bad Sport, my father in law put a screwdriver in there and tried to turn, but said he couldn't. Maybe he was just afraid to force it too much or couldn't get a good grip on it, but that was my first suggestion for fixing it and I'll try it myself first thing tomorrow.

67Dart273, I really appreciate your response as well. I do a lot more searching and reading on here than I do posting, and your posts have helped me a LOT!