Top end of the gauge or bottom end? If top end, then, yes, the sensor, limiter, or gauge is off; it ideally would be around 1/3 up from the bottom in the normal with that level of temps. One other check you can do is to read the sensor resistance (sensor connection to sensor body) at a given temp; at 175 degrees on the t'stat housing measured with a temp gun (which is maybe 180-185 in the top front of the head), then the sensor resistance should be in the 20-25 ohm range.