Biohazard
There are a lot of cars that get their interiors done in black. I think it's because it's easiest to find parts reproduced in that color and it does tend to go with all exterior paint schemes. I think that one of the main reasons I drool over a red interior is because it tends to really pop and has sort of a retro look to it.
Black tends to hide details. - That doesn't mean that I don't think they look good, I just think that they lack the WOW factor that colors like red give you.
If I had to choose between column A and column B I guess I'd choose black door panels. I think that with as much of the rest of the interior being kept black, the red panels would seem to break up the overall 'flow' of the interior. I don't know if my trend of thought makes any sense to you. I guess I'm trying to say that I feel the black/red/black door theme (with red seats) seems a bit disjointed compared to the black door theme with red seats.
Regardless of which way you choose you really can't go wrong. They'd both be great but I'd go black.