Consider the cost/issues with 5.7, it just makes the 5.2/5.9 an easy choice, plus they are almost free and $1500 will make more than 5.7 HP . Having one of the best production short blocks helps too.
I couldn't agree more...... but I also know some like the new hemi in their classic and that is cool too. I also know a new hemi in your classic will make it worth a lot more than a 5.2/5.9 magnum, even if they run the same E.T.
But for me, magnummopar's statement holds true..... and I'll throw in the LA with the magnum.