X pipe H pipe or side by side

If you hold your hand behind a tailpipe, the exhaust flow feels like a continuous stream, but it's actually a series of pulses, each of which is created every time one cylinder's exhaust valve opens in the firing order. On a typical V8 engine, one cylinder on each bank fires within 90 degrees of crankshaft rotation of another cylinder on the same bank. The resulting exhaust pulses are very close together as they travel through the exhaust system and on some vehicles they create a popping noise. H-pipe sections were first installed to quiet this exhaust noise. When the two close firing cylinders are exhausting on one bank, there is nothing happening in the other bank, so connecting both pipes effectively enlarged the exhaust system, allowing these exhaust pulses to exit through both sides of the system. It was found that, with the addition of an H-pipe, exhaust noise could be reduced by as much as 2 decibels. Adding an H-pipe section also increases power. Even when headers are installed, these close firing cylinders are competing for space in the exhaust pipe after the collector, which creates backpressure and reduces power. Connecting the exhaust pipes allows pressure to escape to the other side of the system, with a resulting gain in low-end and mid-range torque. However, the effectiveness of an H-pipe section decreases somewhat at higher rpm. The increased exhaust gas velocity at high rpm causes most of the exhaust to take the path of least resistance and continue down the exhaust pipe, rather than make the turn into the H-pipe. The solution to this problem is the X-pipe. With an X-pipe section, the two sides of the exhaust system are merged rather than just connected, allowing the exhaust from each bank to easily flow into both exhaust pipes. The exhaust pressure on both banks is equalized and power is increased at all engine speeds.


All of this is correct.


Where I disagree is in that these pipes ALWAYS make power. In most cases, they do not. If you are working with w big budget, and can use multiple cams and have days on the dyno, you may find bit of power in certain circumstances. Usually in very narrow RPM ranges. Then, to verify those results, you need to get on the chassis dyno and flog it to death to verify the engine dyno results. After all that, you go to the track and see if those numbers verify your research.


I called a very well know muffler manufacturer way back in the early 1980's. I was required to use a muffler on my race car. I told him my HP and RPM and then I said I don't want to lose ANY HP. And if that can't be done, I want to minimize my losses.

After 20 minutes of discussion, we actually picked a muffler. I was using an early A body so space was at a premium. Then he dropped the other shoe. The only was to insure a minimal loss with the muffler, was to run a crossover pipe. I told him my results with testing on those things and he laughed. He said that most of the X and H pipes were for noise only. They don't work. To make a LONG story a bit shorter, he told me the crossover pipe MUST be the same diameter as the collector (I was using a 4 inch collector) and that the length can be no LESS than 4 TIMES the diameter in length!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Then he said that is why you don't see drag cars with crossovers. To actually make them work it is almost impossible to make them fit. So I said the PS and Comp guys KNOW they are giving up power and they let it go? He said no, they could possibly find HP with a crossover, but when the cam/exhaust lobe/ exhaust port is correct and you are not required to run a muffler there in no gain.

So again, it depends on application and how well you have ironed out the above systems.