How screwed am I?

Thanks for all the ideas. I'm in Wisconsin. It was a shady couple that had been, looking forward, it was silly of me. The statute of limitations on receiving stolen property is 3-6 years, that's not the case, but still puts me in the clear if they were to try that. I've tried contacting every person on the title to no avail. She was the one that signed off on everything, he just conducted the transaction.

Then all you really need to do is fill the back of the title out as the buyer, take it in and get it transferred.