You probably have seen this thread in your searches but here is one discussing aome pros/cons of tag reproduction. It discusses another source of tags at www.datatags.com
Thanks for the links Scott. I'd already looked at the datatags website but never knew they were the ones that made the Govier tags. The one thread makes reference to a company called TRIM TAGS but it seems they only make GM tags. I think we may try that datatags company and see what luck we'll have.
I know there are a lot of guys concerned about potential fraud when it comes to high end cars but it's really frustrating to own one that's missing that tag and be told it'll cost thousands to get it replaced.