I read this commentary with interest, 'speically the comment of flatness being most of the battle. The one thing that I question is on the dowel pins; I can't see where they do anything to to help the gasket stay in place in the narrow webs between cylinders. It is just clamping pressure and surface friction that keeps them in place in those areas.
With grinding type surfacers still around, the rough surfaces in rebuilds aren't going away IMHO.