For one, to work, they need to be hand fitted. Are you going to pay for that in an OEM deal that don't need it?
Stroke length is a big factor.
Oil wraps around a crank like a blanket. Any time you can lose it you are better off.
Call IJ and talk to Kevin. He will explain to you how wrong you are.
Oh wait, I forgot...he has a vested interest in something he sells.
I can see this is going to go the way of the adjustable PCV valve. I bought one and caught hell for it. Luckily, many guys are using them besides me with much success.
The crank scrapers is no different. If you are bother isn't to spend the time to build an engine, why not spend a few extra dollars for a crank scraper.
Unreal.