Looking for battery recommendations.

Johnson Controls also makes the Super Start batteries for O'Reilly as well.

Was rackin my brain to come up with the second company that makes batteries for O'Reilly. It's East Penn. They make some good batteries. Including the AGM style. O'Reilly has the AGM style in the Super Start brand as well made by East Penn.

East Penn Manufacturing – The world's largest single site, family-owned lead-acid battery manufacturer

Interstate batteries are made by Johnson Controls, which makes 65% of the car, truck, and marine batteries
in the US. They also make batteries for Walmart, and Autozone. They use to make Kirkland batteries for Costco, which now sells Interstate batteries. For the price, and their return/exchange policy, an Interstate battery from Costco is hard to beat.

Sorry Riddler, this doesn't really help you, since you need an AGM battery.
I had one of those reproduction AGM batteries. Was heavy as heck, lasted about 5 years.
Was very expensive.