Dip stick length

My 1963 Shop Manual says 14 pts. Don't know if a 65 is different.
Ok, so I cranked the car, put it in neutral and let it idle for a few minutes. Drained the fluid and put 5 new qts. in it. cranked it and drove it down the street. came back and checked it. 4-1/2" up the dip stick. that's 2" above the full mark. What to do now?
easyrider