Economical replacement rocker arm set?

yes, the rocker arms can become worn, but maybe the tips could be re-dressed, if necessary.
If you are getting new pushrods, first make sure all of the valve stem tips are at the same height. Hopefully, when the heads were done the machinist was careful to grind the valves and seats consistently, so the stem tips end up at the same height, so you can get one length of pushrods which will fit all the valves correctly.
I don't think the machine shop did any valve work. I only asked them the clean them up and make sure they were in good condition.

Ensureing everything is the right height is the reason I was thinking I would just go new.