Be careful when getting a new grommet, some of them aren't pliable enough almost like a soft plastic, and can be a pain to get the filler neck into. This is the one I found on ebay and it seems to work fine. I test fit my filler neck in it (I haven't installed the new tank and filler neck yet)
1967 - 1976 A Body MOPAR FUEL Grommet Gas Tank Seal CORRECT FIT New | eBay
After installing the grommet into the tank lube it as well as the bottom part of the filler neck with a lube, preferably silicone based