Vinyl top alternatives

I've never tried any but what about that stuff you can just peel off when your tired of it?

Plasti-dip? It would look good and the texture would totally work. But it's not really a permanent thing. It would depend on how much time the car spends outside in the sun, but you'd probably only get a few years out of it at the most. Of course you could just peel it off and re-coat it when it started to look bad.