Turns out my recently acquired Formula S had 4 of the 4.5" wide wheels and only the spare was the correct 5.5" wide. Since it also did not have the correct wheel covers I'm thinking maybe they were stolen back in the day. I came up with a set of the Formula S wheel covers and they do not seat properly on the 4.5" wide wheels. I've attached pictures of the one wheel I have that I assume is correct.
Please PM me with what you've got.