What do I need for a proper under-dash rewire?

If it had a map light it likely had the lighting group which included a delay timer on the dome lamp circuit. You might find a tiny light bulb above the ignition switch bezel too. When that delay timer would fail, the owner might hack a lot of stuff trying to end the dome lamp always on and battery kill. Sure I'm only guessing why the wiring was hacked but there had to be some reason for it.
So.. repair the conductors per the diagrams. Once every component is properly connected and chassis grounded then you find which components need replaced.
I'll add that if it were mine, I would totally delete that lighting group. I do use the basics, a glove box lamp or the trunk lamp, but I don't need the dome lamp to remain on while I dig my keys from my purse. Nor do I plan to spread a Rand-McNally road map on the passengers seat and floor.
I can't honestly speak to the lighted key switch issue. Mine is in a chromed bezel. Maybe the 68 model key hole is more difficult to see/ring under that odd shaped color keyed bezel. My total delete plan would delete that lamp too. Anyway, Good luck with it.

Thank you! I don't have the lighted ignition bezel, so I'm not sure what the deal is. The fender tag didn't say anything about it being an option on my car, the only lights it has right now are the dome light and glovebox light. There's a hole in the dash down low about where a map light switch should be

I don’t know if it puts you closer in range on cost, but both Classic and year one have sales that can get you 30% off or so. That’s what I did.
I looked at that, and at least on classic's site, wiring harnesses are marked as non-discount items. Even then, too much $$$ :(

Get ahold of a factory service manual, pull the harness out and go through it wire by wire until it is back to factory. Think about your aftermarket accessories (tach, stereo etc) while you are doing it and make provisions for them. An added bonus of doing this is you can troubleshoot easily after because you know exactly what goes where. Grabbing an assortment of Packard 56 connectors is a must. I got mine on Ebay. Also if you have a spare wiring harness from a parts car, they are invaluable for little bits you cant easily source elsewhere.

Cley
That's what everyone seems to be saying, is the Packard 56 connectors are the way to go.
I'm thinking of a rewire under dash on 67 cuda not looking fwd to it. No way around pulling the dash really. Console and ac just to add to the challenge. Windshield has to come out for dash removal. Snowballs quickly into a **** show lol.
I'll be following along here
Sounds fun:poke:. I won't be doing this until around Christmas time, and it will most likely be a different thread. There will be lots of pictures!