Brand new main bearing nicked. Usable?

Your 1st sentence is the key..... 'for a performance application'. For a lo-po, d-driver, or cruiser use, where the rod oiling is adequate as-is, no need for full groove, and it may lead to accelerated main wear at the lower oil pressures (idling, daily driving around town). That is the reason that I said it is a trade-off, and I would encourage folks to understand why to go one way or the other.

Now here is an interesting compromise at least for 360's: 3/4 groove.... never knew that existed.
What main bearings for a high performance engine?
Agreed.
Yes I believe federal mogul makes a 3/4 groove for the sbm.
Part of the point I was trying to make was even if you told Mahle clevite you were building a bracket drag motor (which I did) they will still try to convince you to go with a 1/2 groove bearing.
There is not a consensus on full grooved.
But yes for a regular engine I agree they are not necessary.