Wiesco protru or icon

I asked the question mainly due to the piston material of each. Icon is a 2618, wiesco 4032. Had been shooting 125 on the factory hypers for a long time. Upon teardown had one with the top land broken, and most of the top compression rings broken, truck was still running the same numbers but blowby was so bad it pushed the dipstick out the tube. Im leaning toward the icon, mostly due to the fact that i know nothing about the durability of the wiesco