My Duster was stolen

That's not ethical. Sounds to me like you need to go over his head to the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigations. He's not the end all be all. He's doing something illegal if what you say is true. You need to call him on it.
I'm going to try to see if the State Investigative Bureau can help me out. I'm calling them tomorrow and going to run this by them and see what I can do.... Otherwise I do not know what to do And what I am saying is true. I have NO REASON to fabricate anything related to this.