Just like you said about the Caribbean, it depends on where you go. I’ve been all over the Caribbean and would always choose Hawaii over it. Not Oahu, the other islands.
Kinda like Puerto Rico, it’s not what the rest of the islands are really like.
Very true, there are Islands in the Caribbean I have no plan to ever visit again such as Martinique. One of my coworkers went to Kauai with his son and loved it. Very few people and not touristy. Like I said I would like to visit the islands someday...