‘67 Barracuda Reverse Bezels Don’t Fit

Went to install reverse light bezels only to find they don’t fit. There’s a gap between the bezel and the rear valance. I grabbed an original off the car and it fits great.

Am I missing something maybe a gasket of some kind? Thanks for the help

Painted bezels are new and don’t fit
Sandblasted bezel is original off the car and fits

EB1E3797-30E0-432C-89F6-4E0F268039BD.jpeg C0460D88-0824-4C2B-9014-AC12E6371FF4.jpeg 1A7970E1-FECE-4CFA-91BD-3862A587ABBD.jpeg 2A780DBD-938A-4B46-8F14-C84CF8DFBB79.jpeg 40DE7325-54BC-4469-AB0A-35F7FF29B571.jpeg