PCV has whistle and/or whine

The OP says that he is having problems with a whine/whistle stating he has tried different traditional PVCs with no luck. I suggested the M/E Wagner because it's made differently than a normal PVC. My thinking it would solve the whine/whistle because it's fully adjustable to work on any engine without having to piece something together. I've found that most of the time but not always I have to get out the wallet to fix issues with these engines..lol

I agree. I only suggested the $25 valve as a tool to tinker with flow to see if it goes away with a little less flow. I didn't mean as a permanent fix as I should of stated.With all the valves he's bought now he could have the one you suggested. I hope the grommet fixes your issue. It sounds very plausible.