Refurbishing my non-rallye instrument cluster

Buy a silver Sharpie from your local craft store. It will look fine if you're not doing a 100+ point resto....Covers the yellow nicely & you won't notice once it's in the car :)
I agree. We have tried everything with the bezel trim; free hand painting, masking then spray painting, and finally with a silver metallic Sharpie....and the Sharpie wins by far !