1969 Dodge Dart - Instrument Cluster Bezel and Lens

My guess is that the pins on the OEMs were heat melted down. you could try that with a flat metal rod heated enough to melt the plastic.
or perhaps a speed nut if it is not visible when installed.

adhesive would work but be careful of runs or drippage and visibility from the outside when installed

This, they are "staked" with a hot iron. You should be able to use a soldering iron. You'll probably ruin the tip doing it, but it gets it done.