Stop in for a cup of coffee

Think of it this way Dave, a new roof would suit me fine regardless of it's construction but in 15 or so years, the right roof will help sell the house, add value, and sell in a reasonable time.
I understand your thinking, but I’m not sure the pool of buyers in the market then would agree.

To you, it’s a big design feature...to a prospective buyer it may just be a roof that they need to worry about.

Would a dimensional shingle roof really reduce the price by as much or more value as the increased cost of an original roof than you save?