Recomedations For New SBP Rotors?

The Bendix rotor PRT 1054 that you have a note added - Returned to NAPA. Was that due to the Hat area not being machined?
I see this item listed on most of my searches and they have the highest reviews. I'm skeptical because they are also the lowest priced in comparison as well.
Here's snip from my spreadsheet. Slightly dated but will give you some numbers.
Rotor thickness minimum 4-piston KH?

OK The place was 'brake performance' not 'warehouse'