Crazy Gas Gauge

Non OEM sending units at not worth the metal they are made from.

The
Silver Salute with a black wick
Is a capacitor to reduce noise on the radio and help the instrument voltage regulator last longer.

The typical sender will have a resistance range some are 10 to 80 ohms. Part of the problem is the float arm is way too short, the other is the aftermarket senders are not designed for the shape of the tank.

As Lord sparky pointed out there are a ton of posts about the issue.

Your best bet is if you have your original and it is not a rust bucket send it out to be rebuilt.

There are devices called meter match that can help.

This is a good post
Close as you will come to getting an OEM fuel sender..

Here is another

Fuel Gauge Sending Units compared