Poor idle and off-idle performance after distributor swap

I made a mark on the distributor for reference before taking it out to swap cans, afterward I put it in the exact same spot and it was like 10 degrees off. Weird that just swapping vac cans would drastically change the orientation of the distributor.

Of course they will. There is no guarantee that a vacuum advance is going to be exactly the same as another. The way the vacuum changes timing is the rotation of the breaker plate. So if the arm is a tiny bit off from the original it will change the timing.

Remember dist. degrees are half crank degrees. So if you only change something in the dist. makes a difference of 5 degrees, it will change 10 degrees at the crank.

Don't you have a timing light?