The 8 1/4 thread

Been through this thread, read all the posts now. I think it needs to be pointed out that so far I see no evidence to support two different housings.

Dr. Diff was quoted as saying he only knows of one pinion offset machined into the housings, the pictures of housings showing the "difference" look no different to me outside of camera angle, 1970-Dart specifically pointed out that he swapped 3.55 gears into his housing that came with 2.45 hears by using the correct carrier.

There is no argument with there being a different carrier based on the gear ratio, but I think the argument that the housing is different is due to the wrong carrier being used for the ring gear.

Buy a 2.45 axle and try and swap 3.55's onto the original carrier and the gears won't mesh. Buy and use the correct carrier for the 3.55's and I doubt there will be any problems.

If there is in fact truth to the supposition that there is a 2.45 housing versus a 2.56/2.71/2.92/3.21/etc. housing, then there needs to be more detailed info presented. At least measurements or something more than just pictures saying "these are different" when they look the same to me.

Not trying to bust anyone's chops or call anyone out, but if this is supposed to be the definitive thread on 8.25's, then it should be correct. So far I don't see supporting info to call it that.

Carrier bearings, axle splines, Dana 35 vs. 8.25, etc. are all different issues and unrelated to this.

DionR sounds right - no one has presented any firm evidence that there are two different housings, and several people have posted things that make me think there is only one housing (though there are two carriers). It would be great if Halifaxhops could respond to DionR's post #353.

I'm not sure whether there are one or two housings, but unless someone can show the two housings side by side, or at least from the same angle, give some measurements, part numbers, or point to a Chrysler document that mentions two housings, I'm going to have to assume that there is only one. I've heard this two-housing theory on other pages, but there's a LOT of contradictory information out there on 8 1/4s.

This really needs to be settled if we can. I appreciate Halifaxhops and everyone posting about this, but if the original post is incorrect, the thread should probably be deleted. Most people aren't going to read 300+ posts to figure out what is correct, they'll just go with what's in post #1.