To throw in all of life's variables would make the conversation pointless. I mean, I COULD find a 440 magnum complete and in great shape for 50 bucks at the widow's sale..... That's why I funneled it to specific: Has the 318 become the BETTER choice than the 340 in todays market prices?? 30 years ago the answer would have been NEVER! But today ????? I say yes, the 318 is a better choice than the 340 with a restricted budget.