oil pressure disappeared.

Sounds kinda messed up.

What exactly is "thinner gasket's" and a windage tray? Never heard of such!

Must have sucked something in the pump or broke the pickup.

Seems if your pickup was hard bottomed to the pan you have noticed such when re-installing it!

What pan? Correct pick-up for it? What thinner gaskets and windage tray?

I previously had 2 cork gaskets and a metal windage tray. Now I have a windage tray rubber gasket combo. Probably a 1/8-3/16" shorter. Since I use studs and the gasket is rubber and no RTV is used, I am tightening the pan up and it could press up against the pickup and either plug it or crack it. No way to feel that happening. I should have remeasured the drop of the pickup but I did not. The pan and pickup were used for many miles. The pickup is a 440 source pickup designed for stroker motors. It is narrow at the threaded end so that is does not hit the crank..
1271017b.jpg
Many pickups are welded by the threads and the flange hits the crank. I cannot see the bottom end of this pickup to see if there are stops, say 1/16-1/8 inch to prevent it from sealing against the bottom of the pan. If I measured before to get it close, I could have had it 1/16" away.