COMP Cams Nostalgia Plus

Looks like a step backward. The much bigger exhaust duration is a gimmick for sound, and while it can give a slight mid-range bump, there's better ways to get good performance and a good sound without the compromises.
Your original cam choice is better IMO.
By leaps and bounds his original choice is better. This is so typical of people. Ask about a part, get the thumbs up then go with something else.

Have at it. Just know that second choice that got the magazine fluff has Chevy lobes on it. Have a nice day!