What should I do?

I have 66 Valiant and wanted to change to a Barracuda dash. Saw an ad for early Bar raced a parts by FC7Demon340. I sent a message about a dash and some other parts. I was told this was a tach dash and agreed on 500.00 for the complete dash. I got the dash and was very disappointed in what I got and sent him a message and expressed my dissatisfaction with the dash. He told he sent it insured and was going to file a claim with the shipping company. To me this isn't shipping damage, I will post a few pics and you can decide. IMG_20220202_155537.jpg IMG_20220202_155457.jpg IMG_20220202_155629.jpg IMG_20220202_155553.jpg IMG_20220202_155411.jpgIMG_20220202_155418.jpg IMG_20220202_155424.jpg