This “authentic” repro starter splash shield says it fits 67-72 A-Bodies - NOT!
The upper one is for A bodies and not reproduced. I’ve been able to find a couple of good used ones.
Hopefully AMD will refund / credit for incorrect items. You should send them pictures you posted here and "maybe" they'll actually re-produce an accurate part. Bummer, at least you were able to locate a good used one.